The main problem I found with Duel, was that the action felt too slow. Nick Hancock may like to add suspense, but it felt as though he was dragging things out. Millionaire works because there is considerable risk/reward on each action, and people think of what they would do in the same situation. But in a competition, faster action tends to make for better viewing, especially when not every decision in Duel is as critical.
The format would work better as a 30-45 minute show, and with less money in play. On the one hand, there was considerable amount of money in the jackpot, but players tended to take the money and run at the first opportunity. The rules were then changed, and there were several jackpot winners in a row, turning the balance the other way.
I have some ideas on how to improve Duel itself. These ideas can be used freely, I permanently and irrevocably waive all rights associated with this message and the ideas contained within.
When you win a game of Duel, instead of winning a cash prize, you win a chip with a certain value of money. This chip can be used as a backup chip, so that you can continue playing if your run into trouble.
The values of the chips are as follows:
After 1st game: £2,500 chip
After 2nd game: £5,000 chip
After 3rd game: £10,000 chip
So on your 4th game, you can have accumulated up to 3 backup chips, as well as the 10 game chips. Backup chips can be used to cover possible answers on the machine.
If you lose a game, you win the combined total of the backup chips you have remaining. So if you win two games, lose your third, and have used no backup chips, then you win £7,500.
When a backup chip is used and placed on a wrong answer, the chip falls into the machine, and the jackpot increases by the chip's value. Using a backup chip can be expensive, as it decreases your winnings if you place it on the wrong answer. There is no obligation to play any backup chips if the player doesn't want to.
When a backup chip is placed on the right answer, then after the question's completed, the chip pops back up, just like a usual chip. It makes sense to put a backup chip on the most likely answer to the question.
The jackpot starts at £20,000, and increase in stages of £500. This means that the jackpot can become high, but not too high for the production team to risk a large amount of money. Lower amounts of money have also worked well in Deal or No Deal, as people associate more with the contestants when they watch them making similar decisions to their own.
Duel's a format that I'd like to see again, just a bit faster this time!
