I was thinking about her as well when I saw the board, though I'd probably counter with $195,000 so that Banker would be more likely to accept it. Easy deal at $211,000 if it wasn't accepted.

Andrew: Counter with $306,500 + my case as a souvenir when there was 4 cases left.

Jorge: Counter with $306,500 + my case as a souvenir with 5 cases left. Would've reluctantly dealt at $119,000 if that failed.

Toni: Hard to say with the bonuses, but probably counter with $76,500 + my case to keep as a souvenir with 5 cases left, obviously dealing $95,001 if that failed.

Andrew: Counter at $200,000 at 5-case, if rejected $275,000
Jorge: $277,000, no counter.
Toni: $40,001, no counter. An insane game.

Michael: Would've countered with $55,000 at the stage he did

Monica: Definitely wouldn't have dealt when she did. As there was no prove-out I really can't say what I would've won from there, but if the next case was a low amount I might have been cheeky and tried to counter with the current offer + the car.

David's Deal or No Deal Island Finale Game:

$1,523,000 like every other sane person in that studio.

Thankfully for our viewing pleasure and unfortunately for NBC they had a total psychopath playing that game.