Now I know this idea has been mentioned before about the show and the way it would work. But would you like to see a celebrity version of the show. Say it lasted for just one week and out of the 22 "celebrities" they picked just 6 and the money goes to charity.

To be honest i'd rather not (at least not yet anyway) as the chances are the celebrity people would be a bunch of nobody's who are famous for kissing a footballer or something along them lines and also i'd feel they'd play up to the cameras.

But if they did who would you like to see play?

Nah...I don't think playing for charity would work. It takes away a lot of the risk element - I know there's still some risk involved in that the celebrities would feel responsible if they ended up blowing all the money for their chosen charity, but I don't think it would be as tense as it is with people playing for their own money. The idea of the banker actively trying to prevent charities getting money would feel a bit odd, too.

It would be unfair if contestants stayed there for ages, And it would not work very well

The only way I think it will work would be as a one-off for Children in Need or something, and have Noel playing.

Any other celebrity will seem forced and boring.

No celebrity version for me,it'd be strange withthe banker trying to con a charity out of their money. Noel playing, for charity or otherwise, would be good - perhaps people could pledge money for charity to see him play... but who would host?

Jon Culshaw?????



Maybe just maybe this birthday might just have a few more suprises

Jon Culshaw as Noel = BRILLIANT IDEA!