That's a great breakdown of the squad walsh. A couple of observations/opinions:
Scott Carson - I've had the oppertunity to see him up close for Liverpool a couple of times and I've got to be honest, he doesn't inspire me with confidence. Paul Robinson is going to be one of England's most important players going into this World Cup. If he gets injured then I don't think England have adequate replacements. As you said, David James is prone to the odd mistake and when he's in an England shirt, the defence infront of him doesn't seem to have much confidence in him. Carson his prone to making mistakes himself, and while he's a good shot-stopper and good in one-on-one situations, he has no real command of his area and does have lapses in concentration.
Wayne Bridge - Ashley Cole was taken off today with a problem in his thigh. He's going for a scan tomorrow and I'd imagine Eriksson is praying the damage is not serious as I don't feel Bridge is up to the task of replacing him. Bridge himself doesn't look to be as fit as he should. For me, Cole is one of the best left-backs in the world, infact I don't think there's anyone better than him, so it's a difficult task for anyone to replace him but especially Bridge. Defensively he's not as good as Cole and offensively he's not as good as Cole. If Cole's injury is serious then England's opposition will target that area as their weak spot with Bridge and Joe Cole on that side.
Owen Hargreaves - When the squad was announced I thought he was going in there as a defensive midfielder and a right back. However, Carragher played today at right-back and seems to be second choice there to Neville. Carrick seems to be the first choice defensive midfielder if England decide to play using a defensive midfielder with Lampard and Gerrard pushing forward. Carragher seems to be back-up in that position too. If that's right, what is the point of Owen Hargreaves in the squad? He should have been sacraficed for another striker.
Theo Walcott - This is a massive gamble given the state of the fitness of England's strikers. I have a bit of a problem with Sven taking him as a 1 of 4 strikers. Of the other 3 strikers he selected one of them won't play for another 3 weeks at the earliest, one of them isn't a natural goalscorer and the other, England's main goal threat, is suffering from lack of sharpness, lack of games and appears to have niggling injuries. This is potentially England's downfall.
Walcott being brought as a striker is there to score goals. Maybe it's just me and I'm being incredibly stupid for saying this, but taking Walcott, given England's striking situation, suggests to me that Sven expects him to score goals given the chance. Otherwise he would have taken him along as part of a 5 man strikeforce with another natural finisher (well, as natural as you can get with the options he had).
In a crucial goalscoring situation e.g. the game is tied 0-0, 90th minute and an England striker has an oppertunity to score with a one-on-one with the keeper - who would you most want it to fall for? Owen, Rooney, Crouch and Walcott in that order would be my choice. Lets throw Bent, Defoe and Johnson into the mix. In what order would you place them?
It's obvious Walcott's main threat is his pace right now. That's fantastic in the right situation but England need goals from their strikers - I'm not convinced Walcott is the man to do that in an occasion like the World Cup, without having played a competitive match for Arsenal.
Peter Crouch - Thought he was fantastic today, aside from his hat-trick. What England really miss when Rooney isn't playing, apart from a creative spark, is someone who has the ability to link the midfield and the attack, I think Crouch does that well for England in a different way. Today he held the ball up well and waited for support to arrive and he showed his ability as a targetman when he headed the ball on or chested it down for someone to have a shot. I think Owen is much better when he plays with a big guy, someone who'll take the knocks and lay the ball on for him. He's always been like that - with Heskey at Liverpool and Shearer with England in the past.
_________________ I think you'll be back...
Member of the Noel's Beard Fanclub.
|