Thought Dickie (or should I call him Craig?) played a good game, there. At the start, the introduction took so long, I thought there might have been a first-offer deal on the cards! Turns out it was to fill the time after Dickie's rapid no deals.
At 8-box, I felt sure the offer would have been around £16,500 on an effective 4-4 board. To have offered £22,000 is very generous, and one look on Dickie's face could tell he was out of here before he asked for any advice!
To describe how good offers are, relative to how much players can expect to win playing on, I'm going to invent some new language. Using the expected value of a board at 2-box (in this case, the average of all dealable offers), we can compare the offer on the table with the EV, and give it a score of its worth value:
EV++ Significant potential to win more
EV+ Likely to win more on average
EV+= Small gain playing on
EV= Little/no gain continuing
EV=- No gain continuing, can win more on average going all the way in some circumstances
EV- Risk of negative equity on average
EV-- Serious financial consequences playing on
Also, one that doesn't fit into the above category:
EV+- Unbalanced, EV could go either way depending on battle of wills/board stability
So, here's what I worked out...
8-box offer: £22,000
2-box EV: £25,150 (EV+=)
5-box offer: £33,000
2-box EV: £33,300 (EV=)
At 8-box, he had positive expectations, but perhaps not enough to warrant risking £22,000 on. The 5-box scenario that happened this time would be just about right to deal, though if Dickie didn't take this offer, the Banker may have made a higher-than-expected 2-box offer, which he did. (This unexpected EV shift isn't reflected in the stats above.)
So looking at the above, and considering the reaction, it was the right deal for him.
Fascinating info about the bionic ear, no idea that could be done! And good thing you kept Noel in check (bad Noel, naughty Noel!), at least he did something else than go on about blues, and engaged with the players in the wings a bit more. But then, I
Bellieve
Hull be back to his old ways,
Yes I'm sure!
Enjoy the £22,000, Craig/Dickie!